104 Comments

The only remedy at our disposal as voters is to defeat Trump at the ballot box. We have no control over the progress of the Georgia criminal proceeding, so we should refrain from injecting that proceeding with electoral significance it does not have.

You have not written truer words, Robert.

Expand full comment

TC, I merely would add that I see no way forward except by winning enough races up and down the ballot to retake the U.S. House, defend every Democratic U.S. Senate seat, despite an unfriendly map, pick up one more seat in the Senate to render Manchin and Sinema irrelevant should either be reseated, and, of course, hold the White House. Additionally, we’ll have to defend democracy at the state and local levels.

I would note I have underscored our many challenges to amplify Robert’s point that were we to get caught up in the daily blow-by-blow discussions of the indictments, we would do so at our peril.

Expand full comment

Good points but what no one is talking about is the Senate races in 2024 and the Republican incumbents and several Democrats who are at risk. This is where there needs to be a focus starting now.

Expand full comment

Stephen, I agree; hence my phrase “despite an unfriendly map.” While I could be wrong, I am inclined to believe that increasingly more of us are rallying around Senators from red states who are up for re-election.

Expand full comment
founding

“...we would do so at our own peril.” Amen!!

Expand full comment

I'm 99% guessing that Manchin is going to switch to independent and Sinema is finito in AZ for sure.

Expand full comment
founding

We cannot take either of these two for granted. They add to our challenge as we seek to hold the Senate. Every Senate candidate should be the best we can put up and fully supported by Dems.

Expand full comment

Let's be clear about what WE, active Democrats need to do starting today.

The DOJ around the US is doing a fine job hunting down witches in America. So far they have found the crime boss witch 91 times✌️.

And his MAGA support witches 10s.of times..(Are Rudy and Sidney Powell not from the central casting witchery,?)

Our job is to create a LANDSLIDE WIN in 2024!!

What we get to do is support candidates and policies that are doing great good for the American people including robust economic recovery, rebuilding infrastructure, returning critical manufacturing to the US, returning American leadership to the world stage, passing national legislation to guarantee a women's right to choose, facilitating lower drug costs, and so forth..

And what does the GOP get to do?

Support a mob boss who perpetuated an electoral crime spree and his senior MAGA attack dogs.

This is no where near a level playing field..

If each of us can drive 5 to 10 additional Democratic votes to the polls in 2024, we will get Uncle Joe 87 million votes, 10 million more votes than in 2020.Lets enjoy this blessed time for Dems and go get A LANDSLIDE

Expand full comment

And if 2024 is too far away for you, Virginia is having their elections in 2023! There are over 400 candidates vying for office in the November general election.

https://ballotpedia.org/Virginia_elections,_2023

and my favorite:

https://postcards4va.com/

Expand full comment

Lynell, I just signed up for postcards for Virginia and I shared the information with 10 of my friends. We all live in Southwest Virginia, so I hope some of them will get involved. I know they care. I just don't know how many things they already have going. Thanks so much for sharing this organization. I'm surprised I wasn't aware of it, but now I am! ☺️ Thanks!

Expand full comment

I'm writing postcards 4 VA as well. :-D Throughout the year there are many campaigns to write for. Check out postcardstovoters.org and also ActivateAmerica.vote, which has campaigns going on now.

Expand full comment
Aug 16, 2023Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

Thanks, Lynell, for this reminder of what's at stake for us in VA, and by association, the whole Country. Abortion rights, climate, voting rights, guns, and if we DON'T hold the general assembly blue, we'll see the presidential campaign launch of the disaster that's Gov. SweaterVest/SnitchLine/CRTLies Youngkin. To add to the postcards effort, I've coordinated 8,000 pre-printed cards to our County neighbors - all but strong Republicans (VA doesn't register by party; we have a data base that might be totally wrong). Our volunteers write a note, an address and add a stamp. Turnout, turnout, turnout!

Expand full comment

Wow, Linda, 8,000 pre-printed cards? That's impressive! The good news is that the House has a slim R majority, so it's not impossible to reclaim it. Expanding our Senate majority would be nice, too.

The other good news is that governors can't serve back-to-back terms!

Thanks, Linda; it's nice to be on the same team with you.

Expand full comment

Just signed up for postcards. Thanks for the link!

Expand full comment
Aug 16, 2023Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

I too signed up for 400 postcards to Virginia. Very satisfying! I always finish the short note on the postcard (urging the receiver to vote) with: Our democracy needs us!

Expand full comment

400 is a nice, round number, Karen! I like to say things to let them know we're in this together - as Joyce Vance always says!

Expand full comment
Aug 16, 2023Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

As a measure of what we are up against, a friend recently met a man and his 10 year old son. The 10 year old exclaimed, “I HATE Biden!” My very Democratic friend, ever curious, asked, “You do? Why is that?” The 10 year old replied, “Because all he does is spend money -- on PEOPLE!” Umm... yea......

Expand full comment
founding

GOP Indoctrination. You witnessed it.

Expand full comment
Aug 16, 2023·edited Aug 16, 2023

"out of the mouths of babes" Art Linkletter (?)

Expand full comment

Man-o-man, I sure wish that “witch” was not such a derogatory term. Surely I’m not the only pagan who feels this way. I agree with your other points, but starting off by comparing me to tfg....

I may be going out on a limb here, but I think most pagans, and many witches, are firmly opposed to the current Republican platform.

Expand full comment

Merrill, I love that word: A LANDSLIDE! ❤️

Expand full comment

A landslide is only good if we get the electoral college numbers. That’s all that counts.

Expand full comment

That's an important distinction, stephen. Thanks. I am still "chewing" on the electoral shenanigans that stole the presidency from Al Gore and Hillary Clinton. Surely, the R's will play that card again for all its worth, and continue to assail voters' access to voting. I hope 'we' can find ways to prevent the denial of voting access...such as when the R's moved a polling place only 5 days before an election. Or thinning the rosters by whatever means.

Expand full comment

LANDSLIDE! It’s such a good word to hear you mention. It’s the goal for us all!

Expand full comment
founding

Great post; Our job is to create a LANDSLIDE WIN in 2024!!

“What we get to do is support candidates and policies that are doing great good for the American people including robust economic recovery, rebuilding infrastructure, returning critical manufacturing to the US, returning American leadership to the world stage, passing national legislation to guarantee a women's right to choose, facilitating lower drug costs, and so forth..”

Expand full comment

I totally agree, Merrill. And for this of us who are retired, I feel that accomplishing that goal should be easy.

Expand full comment

Robert, a wonderful newsletter today. I feel as you do: Fani Willis is a fantastic example of the best in America. Honesty, integrity and courage to face these criminals and do justice for each and every one of We The People. She is a true hero, on the biggest scale. Thank you.

Expand full comment
founding

Agree, great newsletter. Also, it takes courage among our age group to admit you are not a Star Wars fan :)

Expand full comment

I am not a Star Wars fan. I watched the early ones, and enjoyed them, but am out of that cultural loop. I also don’t like sports analogies, but decided not to tell Robert….lol.

Expand full comment

Ditto, Elisabeth! Maybe there are more of us than we know?

Expand full comment

A “silent majority”?

(Where have I heard that phrase before?)

Expand full comment

But he could still quote the movie!

Expand full comment

I will let the words of Stuart Stevens speak for me: “This is basically a Rico indictment of the Republican Party. As it should be. Every Republican elected official who refused to acknowledge the winner of the 2020 election is an unindicted co-conspirator. “

Expand full comment
founding

True dat, Annette!!! Those R's deserve to be indicted, too, and barred from holding public office. What happened to Lindsey Graham, whose call to Raffensperger started this GA ball rolling (thank you, god -- that's why Brad taped the Trump call)?

Expand full comment

FINALLY! Mark Meadows indicted!!!

My thoughts of Fulton County DA Fani Willis with her strength and tenacity bring back to me a sense of pride in our country. I see she is only 52 years old and it's exciting to think of what else her future will bring in leadership for this nation.

Expand full comment

I too was thrilled to see Mark Meadows indicted!

Expand full comment

Finally, the mafia Don is indicted on racketeering charges. Perfect.

Expand full comment

Yes, Minnesota, with his Consigliere Rooty Tooty Ghouliani, originally prosecuting mafia mobsters for the Southern District Of New York under the same RICO laws. Remember? How rich! Shakespeare is smiling down on us....

Expand full comment

Minnesota! I like it but I’m adding to it “Don the mafia don”.

Expand full comment

This indictment is going to cost The Defendant money, big money. I wonder if his supply of OPM will cover it all. He's got his own legal expenses but he's also going to have to subsidize the defenses of 18 co-defendants, for fear that any he fails to aid may decide to flip. And Willis can surely cite his behavior in other courts to argue that he should have to put up a cash bond to ensure he respects the integrity of the process. The same may apply to his co-defendants as well. It'll be a big bill, and if his partisans don't pay it, he'll have to use his own money.

Expand full comment

¢a$h bond$! Lot$ of 'em! With lot$ of zeroe$ to the left of the de¢imal point!

Expand full comment

Considering he's being investigated for how he used the funds???

Expand full comment

More good news out of Georgia- Bert Jones, the fake elector turned lieutenant governor of Georgia will be investigated!!

From the Atlanta Journal-Constitution

“A state agency is moving ahead with plans that will determine whether Lt. Gov. Burt Jones faces criminal charges as part of a scheme to overturn the 2020 presidential election in Georgia.

Jones is one of 30 people who prosecutors said participated in a conspiracy to overturn the election but were not charged in a Fulton County indictment released late Monday. But Jones may yet face charges, and his fate will rest with a special prosecutor who will determine whether further investigation is needed.

Pete Skandalakis, executive director of the Prosecuting Attorneys Council of Georgia, said he has reviewed the Fulton County indictment and hopes to appoint a special prosecutor to consider Jones’ actions soon.

In a social media post Tuesday afternoon, Jones did not directly address a possible investigation of his actions. He said Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis had spent millions of taxpayer dollars and 2½ years “orchestrating a constant media and PR campaign for the sole purpose of furthering her own political career.”

“While the Fulton County district attorney continues to pursue the political vendettas of the past — I have and will continue to look forward, solving the most pressing issues facing our city and our state,” Jones added.

The steps toward a possible investigation of Jones follow Monday’s indictment of 19 people — including former President Donald Trump — on allegations that they conspired to overturn Democrat Joe Biden’s victory in Georgia in 2020.

Jones, a state senator at the time, played a prominent role as Republicans in the General Assembly considered rejecting Georgia’s official presidential electors and appointing a slate of Trump electors instead.

Jones and a handful of other senators pressed for a special legislative session to consider appointing the Trump electors, supported lawsuits that sought to void the results and pressed Vice President Mike Pence to reject the official results when Congress met to certify Biden’s victory.

Monday’s Fulton County indictment did not name Jones, but it referenced his efforts to rally support for overturning Biden’s victory. It noted that on Dec. 7, 2020, a tweet by “unindicted co-conspirator Individual 8″ urged Georgians to “call your state Senate & House Reps & ask them to sign the petition for a special session.

We must have free & fair elections in GA & this is our only path to ensuring every legal vote is counted.”

The tweet matches one that Jones shared on the same date.

The indictment mostly notes Jones’ role as one of the fake Republican electors. In that capacity, the indictment says Individual 8 participated in a conspiracy that involved impersonating a public officer by falsely saying they were the state’s duly elected presidential electors, forging fake Electoral College paperwork, making false statements and writings, and filing false documents.

The indictment includes charges against some Republican electors — such as state Sen.

Shawn Still — but not others. It’s unclear whether Willis intended to charge Jones, but she never got the chance.

Last year, Jones objected to being investigated by Willis after she hosted a fundraiser for the eventual Democratic nominee for lieutenant governor, Charlie Bailey.

Jones argued Willis’ political support for his opponent constituted a conflict of interest.

Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney disqualified Willis and her office from questioning Jones as part of their investigation. The judge asked the prosecuting attorneys council — a state agency that assists district attorneys — to appoint an outside prosecutor to investigate Jones.

Skandalakis was waiting for Willis to complete her investigation.

Now that the grand jury has acted, he said he has reached out to Willis to obtain a copy of a special grand jury report on her investigation and to get a briefing on the investigation to date.

With that information in hand, Skandalakis said he will find a special prosecutor to make the final decision on whether more investigation or criminal charges against Jones are warranted.

Finding a special prosecutor may not be easy. Skandalakis said state law limits the special prosecutor’s compensation to less than $60 per hour — not much for many lawyers — plus some travel costs. If the prosecutor wants the help of an investigator or administrative assistant, he or she must bear the cost out of pocket.

It’s unclear how soon Skandalakis will appoint a prosecutor or how soon a prosecutor will make a determination about Jones’ case. But Skandalais said the special prosecutor will not be bound by the timetable of Willis’ case.”

Expand full comment

All hail to Fani Willis!!! I am glad that her name will go down in history as someone who stood up for the rule of law and stood up to bullies.

Expand full comment

A Summary of 3 Indictments...

WaPo Reader identified as "John Hornby2":

"I dreamt of home confinement, permanently, in an ivory tower at bedminster, but, wait for it, where he can SEE the golf course as it is seized & turned into housing for the homeless/immigrants!"

AND,

WaPo reader identified as "The Choobs":

Jack Smith: “You are going down, Trump.”

Fani Willis: “Hold my beer.”

Expand full comment

Drink coffee, Swallow. THEN read comments. (Still laughing at the Fani Willis reference. OMG funny.) Thanks Lynell.

Expand full comment

I thought it was a hoot, and I don't even drink beer!

Expand full comment

I was looking forward to see Lindsay Graham as a co-conspirator. I seem to recall him making a dodgy call to GA officials about the election. He claimed the call was related to his job as senator but it seemed totally unrelated to his job. I’m disappointed.

Expand full comment

I think he may be among the 30 unindicted co-conspirators. If he is, it could be because he struck a deal or may yet do so, or it may just be that his involvement wasn't as central as the others.

Expand full comment
founding

I wondered about LG as well, Betsy, for the same reasons. How I hope he will still be held to account.

Expand full comment

From Denialad: donbialostosky.substack.com

Back when AG Garland was hesitating,

DA Willis began investigating

Trump’s interference in Georgia’s election

And ended up discovering connections.

The call to Raffensperger got her started,

But ’cause Ms. Willis was not fainthearted,

She uncovered how Trump and his minions

Attempted to get inside Dominion’s

Voting machines in Georgia’s Coffee County.

As she kept digging, her inquiry found he

Was head of a multi-state enterprise

Consistent in its goal and organized

To get states to reverse their vote outcomes

And come up with the necessary sums

To give Trump an electoral college win

And give his lawyers what they’d need to spin

Their skirting the Electoral College Act

So a compliant VP could redact

The final count on January sixth.

The project took a lot of dirty tricks

And willing dirty tricksters who would play them—

The list of names is way too long to say them

Here, but eighteen others face her charges.

The reason that the accused list’s so large is

She’s charged them in a case of racketeering.

Their actions of election interfering

Are more than just a bunch of separate crimes;

Together they show criminal designs

That implicate a leader even when

It’s not directly possible to pin

Each act on his direct explicit orders.

If actions of all levels of supporters

Can be shown to contribute to the scheme,

It’s reasonable for the jury to deem

Them all as part of one culpable racket—

The RICO law has been set up to crack it.

Willis lists 161 acts,

Each one supported by the facts,

That were committed, her jurors agree,

“In furtherance of the conspiracy.”

Trump’s “speech falsely declaring victory”

Was the initial act predictory

Of all the actions large and small that followed

Committed by him and by those that swallowed

And chose to act on that initial lie.

Some to be true electors falsely swore,

While others knocked on Ruby Freeman’s door.

And Trump and Giuliani told big lies

To urge state officials to compromise

Election results they knew to be true,

A thing the best of them chose not to do.

It wasn’t just in Georgia that they tried;

In half a dozen other states they lied

And prodded Trump’s fake electors to sign

Certificates that were not genuine.

They tried to undermine the DOJ

And pressure the Vice President to say

That he would count the fake elector slates

That they had manufactured in the states.

The law says even though the racket failed,

The racketeers can still be tried and jailed.

The RICO charge is one of forty-one

Counts the Georgia grand jury has drawn.

The others concern several kinds of lying,

Influencing witnesses and trying

To get officials to betray their oaths.

There’re forgery and perjury both.

There’s fraud attempted and there’s fraud conspired—

So many ways to catch cheaters and liars!

Expand full comment

Well done!

Expand full comment

Follow the indictments against Trump and 18 others in Georgia with this Relationship Map. It includes audio files of the indictments, videos, links to more information and searchable by the type of crime.

https://thedemlabs.org/2023/08/15/follow-trumps-georgia-indictments-with-relationship-map-ai-generated-audio-files/

Expand full comment

Thank you, Robert. Couldn't sleep, drawn to my computer. Reading your comforting thoughts eased my mind. We're going to win this! there are more of us! and a much more 'woke' generation coming to voting age. I think TCinLA's suggestion is right, we should refrain from injecting the Georgia proceeding with electoral significance it doesn't have! And, follow the courage of Fani Willis and the amazing work she's done for our task ahead.

Expand full comment

Did I get this right? It seems to me that that greatest part of the Georgia indictment are: 1. RICO - I love it, corruption, criminality being identified and named and prosecuted. And 2. State-based - no opportunity for pardons. Atty Hubbell has posited some possible squeaking into federal territory, but it doesn't seem very threatening. Did I get this right?

And then, think about this woman, Fani Willis, what persistence, what detail, and how much this will consume her as the trial(s) unfold. How remarkable she is!

Expand full comment

Several things for Trump to think about following his charging, arraignment, and booking in Georgia on charges of interfering in and seeking to overturn Georgia’s 2020 Presidential election results.

First, Georgia has stricter laws governing the conditions of release. Bail can be granted only if there is “no significant risk of intimidating witnesses or otherwise obstructing the administration of justice,” per Georgia’s witness intimidation law. Trump, who has been known to attack judges and witnesses — including his former vice president — on his Truth Social platform, warned in early August after his D.C. arraignment: “IF YOU GO AFTER ME, I’M COMING AFTER YOU!” (In a filing, Trump’s lawyers called the post “generalized political speech, not directed to this case.”) If Trump’s prior behavior is any guide to his likely future behavior it appears he has a very short fuse on controlling his behavior toward witnesses. Just as in the federal indictments he and his attorneys will receive pretrial discovery including witness testimony. Will he seek to disparage and intimidate those witnesses?

Trump will have a mug shot and be fingerprinted: Fulton County Sheriff Patrick Labat has said that if Trump is charged, he will be subject to a mug shot and fingerprinting. The former president did not get a mug shot when he was arraigned in Washington, Miami or Manhattan. Trump has until Aug. 25 to surrender at the Fulton County Jail for booking. The Fulton County jail is a pretty squalid environment. That will undoubtedly be a stark contrast to the gilded Mar-a-Lago or Bedminster Golf Club lifestyle Trump is used to.

Also, in Georgia there are no restrictions on televising of courtroom proceedings including pretrial motions hearings. This will provide increased transparency on court proceedings and see Trump properly treated and portrayed as a criminal defendant. Will this tarnish the image of strength he seeks to portray and protect? Time will tell.

Expand full comment