71 Comments
author

From reader Dorie Lemieux:

A group of us have a healthy habit of reading both Robert’s newsletter and Heather Cox Richardson’s Letters from an American. We see more and more clearly that toxic Republican legislation starts with state legislatures. They have restricted voting rights, reproductive rights, LGBTQ rights, access to healthcare and public education, and lifted controls on gun violence.

Robert interviewed Melissa Walker of The States Project, which has identified pivotal states where Democratic majorities in state house chambers can be saved or gained. The States Project’s vehicle is Giving Circles to raise funds for good Democratic candidates in these pivotal states, and these candidates need our financial support by October 3rd to be freed to focus on meeting their voters to help them win on November 8th.

We can do our part in response to the alarms. Some people live in safe blue states or nearly hopeless red states, but all of us want to help where we can make a difference. Please check out our Tending to Democracy Giving Circle: https://www.grapevine.org/giving-circle/1XQhnyD/Tending-To-Democracy

Together, our small dollars can make the winning difference! THANK YOU!

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

The sooner people donate to the States Project Giving Circles the better. The money can be used more effectively if it is given early so that the campaigns can purchase ads (at cheaper rates the earlier they buy them) and hire staff. If they know they have the money they can plan.

Expand full comment

Also, voting by mail starts BEFORE Election Day!!! So it is extremely important to support Democrats NOW not later! ;-)) Btw, I just donated $50 to the Tending to Democracy giving circle; helped to put them of the $3k mark on their effort to raise $7.5k . . . every little bit helps!

Expand full comment

Thank you, Andrew!

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

Thank you, Robert, for highlighting this path to effective action. With today's necessary attention on our federal government, we also cannot lose sight of the state legislatures!

Expand full comment

Ellie, While I agree and have joined the group, I simply would add, because Republicans ruthlessly are organizing to fill state and local positions with their own people—people who don’t believe in free and fair elections, we also have to remain laser-focused on governorships, Secretaries of State, state A.G.s, and the like. I also understand projects are underway in select states to prevent Republicans from attaining trifecta control—control of both legislative state houses and the governorship.

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022·edited Aug 9, 2022

I'd love the elimination of trifectas-I live in NH. which currently has a Republican QUADRAFECTA -the 4th branch is the Executive Council composed of 5 members who give the governor information about concerns AND can approve/disapprove distribution of monies that involve the state. A perfect example is the current disapproval of monies to support women's health care centers and the Republican majority has voted this down FOUR times this year. (NO abortion issues involved.) There are 4 Republican Men and one Democratic woman member of the Council. That one woman has decades of knowledge regarding health care matters.

Expand full comment

Good news is that New Hampshire is one of the states currently on The States Project list:

https://statesproject.org/our-states/

Expand full comment

Ellie, Though you weren’t addressing me, I, nonetheless, appreciated receiving your note. While I had thought New Hampshire would be on the list, in light of Barbara R’s comment, the validation was most welcomed.

Expand full comment

Barbara, Were I a strategist noting that New Hampshire has both a Republican trifecta and a Republican triplex (Republicans holding the positions of Governor, Attorney General, and Secretary of State), I aggressively would seek out the state’s most vulnerable incumbents and allocate the bulk of the Party’s human and monetary resources to defeating those candidates. That said, I imagine, as a battleground state, New Hampshire is receiving a fair amount of out-of-state support and methodically distributing those resources. The trick, of course, is for Democrats to outsmart the Republicans, and that takes strategic planning and a galvanized base. I would start by enlisting dejected women.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Robert, for mentioning our group, “Tending to Democracy”. As a Florida resident where our legislature is hopelessly gerrymandered, and where the dictator has made it even more so by his meddling, this giving circle gives me great satisfaction that I am doing something that would actually make a difference. If our contributions can flip a couple of other state legislatures, that would be very rewarding indeed.

Expand full comment

As a fellow Florida resident, I agree !

Expand full comment

Very helpful since it is very hard for me to get my meager funds to the places they will do the most good, at the state level. Of course, my main goal is at least two more Dem senators and riding Texas of the vermin running a great state into the ground.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this. I get about 20 texts/day from Dem's all over the country asking for donations. Some from the same person 2 or 3 times. (I'm on a fixed SS income, and it's a challenge to decide to whom and when to donate.) The one's I find most distressing say, "I'm not asking for money. I need your opinion on what's important." Then at the end of the survey, they ask for money. And almost every one starts out with something dire. I've resisted texting STOP because I don't want to negatively impact any campaign. But this might be the answer; Then I can STOP with a clear conscience. Thanks again!

Expand full comment

What initially struck me upon hearing the news of the FBI’s search of Trump’s Florida’s residence was that August 8th was the date nearly 50 years ago when President Richard Nixon was forced to resign the office of the Presidency because of the evidence of crimes that had been discovered by investigators.

Throughout the evening, I particularly was struck, contrary to today, that back in 1974 the Republican Party did not rise to protect President Nixon when evidence of crimes was revealed. Fast-forward to today’s political world, wherein the top Republican in the House of Representatives threatened AG Garland, intimating, when Republicans retake the House, that House subpoenas would be coming his way.

Could we possibly need further convincing that this fall, aside from running on their accomplishments, Democrats, up and down the ballot, need to amply the opposing party’s lack of regard for the rule of law, for the balance of powers, and, last but not least, for truth itself?

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

Regarding the search warrant: I saw one of the pundits say that there’s a chance Trump would not be indicted unless there is more evil afoot than just stashing documents. That made me start wondering what else they know. They mentioned classified information that unfriendly nations would want. So then I put that together with the very act of obtaining the search warrant and I thought, wow, if they know he’s in contact with foreign adversaries, he’s in a lot of trouble. And wouldn’t that make the whole thing urgent? Lordy, I hope he at least can’t run for President again.

Expand full comment
author

The consensus seems to be that something very serious motivated the need for a search warrant to seize evidence. Given Garland's cautious nature, I suspect that Trump has classified information relating to national security.

Expand full comment

All those love letters to and from Putin and Kim....

Expand full comment

Maybe all his love letters to Putin are in that safe.

Expand full comment

Dan Abrams, the chief legal advisor for ABC news, said the same thing. He said if it were only stolen documents it would be overreach and therefore he is convinced that there is much more.

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

Here are two interesting items of speculation to relay regarding today's warranted search of Trump's residence, reportedly for classified documents:

1. To which federal court did DOJ apply for the search warrant? Lucian Truscott reader Mary Hilton raises the possibility of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISA--don't know why not "FISC"): because the target documents were so top secret:

"The FISA court is a tribunal established in 1978 that decides whether to approve wiretaps, data collection and government requests to monitor suspected terrorists and spies.

...Officials won’t say exactly where the FISA courtroom is located inside the bunker-like complex. It’s so secretive, the room is tightly sealed to prevent eavesdropping.

...Eleven federal district judges serve on a rotating basis, usually for one week at a time. All judges have a maximum term of seven years with the FISA court.

And only one person has the power to appoint the judges: Chief Justice of the United States John Roberts.

...The judges come from across the country – in fact, they have to come from at least seven of the US judicial circuits."

https://www.cnn.com/2017/03/08/politics/fisa-court-explainer-trnd/index.html

2. Why was ex-wife Ivana Trump's coffin so heavy and why buried on Trump's golf course? (and how did her body get released to him instead of her adult children?) HCR Facebook reader Melissa Quilter wondered, "I want to know why Ivana’s coffin appeared to be almost too heavy for ten beefy pallbearers to carry, when she was ostensibly cremated. Could there be additional (boxes of) state secrets buried with her cremains?"

https://www.facebook.com/heathercoxrichardson

Expand full comment

very cool. The whodunnit bestseller.....start writing!

Expand full comment

It's hard to imagine how low Kevin McCarthy (R-23rd) has sunk, how absent his sence of morality and propriety has become that, upon learning of the FBI raid at MaraLago, he would threaten the DOJ and Garland. He'll shut them down through endless investigations. What a complete and utter disgrace to our country he is. The thought of Kevin McCarthy and his pit bull Gym Jordan running things in the House has me filled with despair. And gratitude that Schumer and Pelosi have actually accomplished so much for the common man/woman.

Expand full comment

I’ve been saying for awhile that we cannot lose sight of retaining the house. Yesterday on two shows (both MSNBC no less) the “experts” stated unequivocally that the house is lost. I don’t agree with that, and realize it will not be easy, but we must double our efforts to ensure the children don’t take over the house.

Expand full comment

Everyone: pick a toss-up seat near you and fight like anything for it. Donate and volunteer! That’s what I’m doing. I don’t live in CA 45 and I think my district is safe, so I donated to the max and volunteer for CA 45. It’s now toss-up. The House is won seat by seat, not as a general concept.

Expand full comment

And a true miracle would be if CA-23 was turned over. McCarthy is amoral.

Expand full comment

McCarthy terrifies me

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022·edited Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

Outstanding letter, Robert. Thank you.

I do worry about the McCarthy threat re DOJ and Garland.

I want to add a couple of thoughts. The news commentary today is full of the predictable hand-wringing about how the FBI action at Trump’s tax-haven home will be divisive and will energize his base. Even if true, so what? His base doesn’t need energizing. In fact they are energizer bunnies. Let’s stop worrying about them and focus on independents and moderates and get them to the polls. And by the way: Let’s also think about how discouraging it will be if Trump is NOT indicted. I certainly am not suggesting that the indictment decision should turn on voting considerations. But for those who worry about divisiveness, I only say it cuts both ways.

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

My mind always goes to the rural Americans-Black, Latino, Indigenous and White, with five or six kids, and either unemployed or barely employed, who are the most victimized by the nation's prescription drug pricing policy. Yes, the long-term solution is personal wellness and healthy lifestyles, but in the run-up to all that, a price cap on insulin and prescription medication is essential.

Expand full comment
Aug 9, 2022Liked by Robert B. Hubbell

I took your advice to subscribe to Chop Wood, Carry Water and am glad I did. I love that she gives specific things we can do to further our goals. Beyond that, the link to this article was heartening: https://www.thedailybeast.com/dark-brandon-or-how-the-left-stopped-worrying-and-learned-to-love-joe-bidens-alter-ego-lets-go-brandon?ref=scroll We are on the offense! Let's keep running up the score!

Expand full comment
founding

Here is a question that runs through my head on occasion. Imagining that hardcore Trump supporters will never believe any search or eventual legal accountability, and reading the disgraceful response of Minority Leader McCarthy the question(s) is: Will this deep divide eventually end in an explosive and violent moment for our country? How does this end in a way that brings about accountability and justice as well as healing for our nation?

Expand full comment
author

No. there won't be an explosive and violent moment for our country. Will there by sporadic violence? Possibly. But most Americans just was to make a better life for themselves and their families.

And not prosecuting Trump carries the same threats of sporadic violence, plus a coup.

Expand full comment
founding

Thanks Robert. While I agree with your optimism and, in fact, believe we must think in positive terms, keep that mindset and bust our ass to make a difference, Sometimes I find the hardcore willingness to ignore truth, ride with the grievance mentality on the right, hear an Evangelical “Christian” family member offer sound bites and lose my perspective or, at least, wonder about these questions. Better to read you, Heather & Jessica daily and enjoy the great outdoors of Colorado as my wife and I did today. Peace & thanks again.

Expand full comment

I am far more concerned actually by the revelations of the New Yorker article than anything being speculated about the FBI / DOJ search warrant and execution of the search of Mar-a-Lago. Frankly Trump's disregard for careful handling of classified documents and preservation of records is old news. If this is a surprise to anyone they have not been paying attention. We are already aware that 15 boxes of documents were previously removed from Mar-a-Lago, some classified, quite some time ago. What else may have shown up now is speculation. There are far more serious crimes Trump has committed openly and this is but a trifle compared to a failed coup attempt. It is also not unprecedented and very much analogous to the search of Hillary Clinton's email server and that investigation. I suggest everyone, Republicans, Democrats, and the media all take a step back and wait for real facts and information before speculating on what this search warrant means and its implications.

Expand full comment

On 8/4/2022 in a hearing Senator Whitehouse clearly established after the testimony from the FBI that the investigation of Bret Kavanaugh was a sham. NO INVESTIGATION WAS DONE. All the “tips” were ignored. Please listen to the video recording on a spam. This is a stain on our Supreme Court. Another insult to women as rape and abuse were ignored. please demand that this wrong is rectified.

Expand full comment
founding

I went straight to Kevin McCarthys twitter account and told him how ridiculous I thought he was to threaten the Attorney General...Maybe Kevin will have to keep his documents and and clear his calendar now that he is threatening the big boys. Trump got away with these things for awhile but his followers are not proving to be so lucky.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Adaline. I'm not on twitter or I would have done the same. McCarthy is such a "big man" threatening an AG who had bipartisan admiration (at least before TFG) and a sterling legal reputation, for doing what McCarthy knows is by the book and necessary. Yet McCarthy is still too timid to call out TFG, even as 45 is fighting multiple lawsuits for obviously illegal and anti-American behavior. McCarthy is like the school bully whose father treats him with contempt and disrespect, who enters the school yard and picks on anyone who is not likely to engage in a fist fight with him.

It makes McCarthy sound like a child having a tantrum.

Expand full comment

‘……. .his reassurances (Milley) were enough to sustain the fragile coalition of military, intelligence, DOJ, and career officials who maintained constitutional order during the perilous few days surrounding January 6th.’

Suggest ‘surrounding’ be replaced with After J6!

Indeed, considering what Milley wrote in his not delivered resignation letter, it would be reasonable to conclude that he believed trump was not acting in a lawful manner before and during Jan 6. If so, he had an obligation to step up and become ‘the lead link’ in the chain of command!

Capitol police personnel died as a result of the trump led coup! They died!

The so called security plan for that day approved by the very people who maintained constitutional order was inept, corrupt and abysmal! Capitol police personnel died because of this non existent security plan!

We now know that people at each department charged with national security violated their oath of office!

Expand full comment

Republicans and their media mouthpieces sought to eviscerate Hillary Clinton for using her personal email for official business. These same folks should now be called to task for dismissing or excusing Trump's treatment of public records. Expose the hypocrisy in clear and certain terms!

Expand full comment

In 1954, Thurgood Marshall "had" to include four words to his Brown v Board of Education decision to have it approved. Those words were "with all deliberate speed." While that landmark decision helped thousands of children gain access to schools, ten years passed before "with all deliberate speed" became a reality. Hats off to Robert B. Hubble for including and reminding us about "deliberate speed" in today's newsletter. Given that the wheels of justice turn rather slowly, I suggest we supercharge our legislative "engines" and support the 1/6 committee to insure Mafia Don Trump is indicted sooner than later.

Expand full comment

I know this doesn't exactly pertain to today's newsletter, but I think it's useful to highlight how closely DeSantis is following Trump's autocratic tendencies. This appeared in today's Tampa Bay Times and discusses the illegality of DeSantis' removal of the state attorney.: https://tampabaytimes-fl.newsmemory.com/?publink=13c03c459_13485ad

Expand full comment

I am very worried about Strong Man DeSantis stepping into Trump's weakened role in 2024. I know I am not alone in this.

Expand full comment

This may sound extremist but I truly believe DiSantis is a Nazi. He has shown his colors and he wants an authoritarian country where he and his cronies rule. Not unlike tfg but smarter. He has shown his colors in FL and his vision for the country. Florida voters need to stop him. (I spend several months in Fl each year but am not a registered voter…despite the tax breaks, I just can not be a resident until he is gone)!!!

Expand full comment

Do you need to become a FL resident and lead the charge? I get that that would not be easy on many levels, especially for those of us who are older and less energetic. Always keeping in mind that EVERY VOTE COUNTS., even the older, wiser ones.

Expand full comment

Thought about it but my husband is not interested in FL residency. Plus I’m not young and tired of “leading the charge.” Sticking w Illinois to make sure we stay BLUE! Lots of $$$ trying yo change that😖.

Expand full comment

I SO get it. In a similar position in Virginia and Massachusetts...can make more of a difference working on it in VA, but, at least until the last disastrous election, that was easier! Carry on the good fight!

Expand full comment